Sepultura -- São Paulo, Brazil -- December 11th, 2010 - Page 3

jd091 · #21 12-12-2010, 09:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DethMaiden

Oh, come on. Two-fourths of the band that recorded it, excluding the two dudes who turned them into the band that made Roots is a cover band? 2006 Sep was awesome, I'd see them again - and I'd see this show - before I'd ever see Soulfly or Cavalera Conspiracy.

What if Soulfly played an all-Sepultura set? I'd rather see that.

DethMaiden · #22 12-12-2010, 09:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jd091

What if Soulfly played an all-Sepultura set? I'd rather see that.

1) That's never gonna happen.

2) I like Andreas Kisser too much to say I'd rather see that, especially since Max has this high-and-mighty attitude despite the fact that he ruined Sepultura then ditched it.

mankvill · #23 12-12-2010, 10:49 PM

still lolin at 2/4

El Gordo · #24 12-13-2010, 03:28 AM

I saw Sep back in 2002 or thereabouts with Derrick on vocals and they sounded great. Definitely not a cover band. Andreas and Paulo (Igor was still in the band, but since he's not anymore I'll pretend like he wasn't) are fabulous musicians and play extremely tight live. It's not like you're watching some Joe Blow cover band -- these guys are pro's. Agreed that the vocals sound different, but the style is more or less the same... it's not like they got Dio to replace Max or something... even though that would be fucking awesome lol.

MetalIsArt · #25 12-13-2010, 04:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ryan_streets

its a sepultura cover band in my opinion

This bs has lasted long enough. Reunite now.

Wizard in Black 666 · #26 12-13-2010, 06:36 AM

I find it amusing that half the people on this board that talk shit on Sepultura and call them a "Fake cover band" are the same exact people that still praise and stand by the sides of Exodus, Cannibal Corpse, Napalm Death and other bands that have lost prominent and important members. You hate on bands like Sepultura but you still praise and buy the cds of bands like Exodus and Cannibal Corpse(who have lost a lot of important members in their band) and you go on about how they still kick ass and ect....

Since everyone see's Sepultura as a coverband I guess I can say I think the current line up of Exodus is a "cover band". Since Cannibal Corpse is missing original members I guess we can all go ahead and label them as a "cover band" as well? What about Napalm Death? There are absolutely no original members left in Napalm Death anymore.....Yet none of these bands get the same level of "shit" that Sepultura gets. Also for the posts saying they suck musically now. I wonder if anyone on these boards have even bothered to check out their last two albums? Dante XXI and A-Lex are stone cold classics.

Indestructible · #27 12-13-2010, 06:44 AM

Old and new Sepultura I am fine with. Max Left in 1996 or 1997 they got a new singer, get over it.

street_burial · #28 12-13-2010, 06:44 AM

I did buy 'a-lex' and it wasnt worth the money at all i was hoping it wouldve been a major improvement from 'Dante XXI'. it was an improvement but very slight, and the untrained ear could easily miss it. and i dont approve of not having all original members unless there is an unforeseen occurance that caused it. but most people still see it as the 'original band' when it isnt.

Wizard in Black 666 · #29 12-13-2010, 06:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ryan_streets

but most people still see it as the 'original band' when it isnt.

Yup....Just like how most people that go see Exodus these days think its the "Original band". I don't see no Paul Ballof(R.I.P)....I thought this was suppose to be the original "Exodus"??? Since Chris Barnes, Jack Owen and Bob Rusay are not in Cannibal Corpse anymore I think we can safely assume the current line up of Cannibal Corpse is a "cover band"......Am I right?....

street_burial · #30 12-13-2010, 07:20 AM

the reason i called them a cover band is because they lost the most prominent member which was Max. noone can match his voice. and those bands who try to....let me find the right word....'mimic' the original band are called cover bands. which is exactly what the 'new' sepultura is trying to do when they played the whole arise album. ive listened to the new guy try 'roots' and in my opinion he fails. but i applaud them for trying. but i think they should just throw in the towel at this point