I think we're in more disagreement on 2012 than any other year I've been posting here.
Only two albums were in both our top 10s. Quite a different story than 2011 if I remember right.
I'm really glad to see pg.lost here though. I didn't see that one on many lists last year, but damn what a fine album. Godspeed beat it out on my list by a narrow margin. #5 and #4, respectively. Last year was a much better year for post-rock than this one was. There wasn't a single post-rock album this year as good as Godspeed's, pg.lost's, or Summer Fades Away's last year. Unless I just missed something pretty substantial.
Kudos for finishing this.