I also don't get the dislike for The Prophecy, because I to like it a lot, and as I said before the guitar solo around 2:05-2:23 sounds a LOT like the chorus of "Scrapping The Barrel" by Alestorm (well technically the other around).
Honestly, every track is a 10/10 for me so..... I don't even know so I'm just going to be odd and pick Only The Good Die Young.
8/16 - Motley Crue/Alice Cooper
9/27 - Styx