On my third listen now. I think it may be a grower, as I've enjoyed it a little more each time. As of now I think it's an okay album.
That said, "okay" is an impressive achievement for this band given their recent track record. Personally, I don't care for the "LOL TATE RUINED THEM" argument (though i do think he's an ass, and in the clear wrong in the recent band split). I can't tell for sure if I like this more than O:MII, but it's without question their best output since then, and possibly the best since Promised Land.
Not that it comes close to Promised Land, which is what it'd take to seriously blow my mind.
"So yeah, monkey prostitution has happened."