Originally Posted by ravenheart
Part of judging something is (should be) first deciding whether you have enough information to make a judgement.
Example, AiC are usually a pretty thoughtful band and their stuff is called what it's called for a reason. We don't know what that reason is, so I agree with Hair Metal Guy (can't remember exact name because he changed it, can't be bothered to scroll and look), we don't yet have enough information to judge whether or not it's a silly title.
I disagree with this, mainly because I believe what was being judged was the title itself, not the potential quality of the music because
of the title. Say the album comes out and the music is awesome, to me that doesn't make the title of the album any more or less silly. Same thing if the music on the album sucks. The album would be shitty and the title would be shitty. Mutually exclusive.