Agreed on Faustian Echoes, it's one of Agalloch's best achievements yet. It blows Marrow of the Spirit out of the water, that's for sure. I think I still like Ashes Against the Grain best though, if only because it has more music to offer than this EP.
The Sword - 12/12
Corrosion of Conformity - 12/18
High on Fire - 12/22