Watch Dogs was definitely unexpected, but looks insanely good. Beyond looks amazing too. Easily the most realistic facial animations I've seen in a game. I honestly said "holy shit" when I saw the trailer.
And of course, The Last of Us makes me a very happy PS3 owner. Post-apocalypic, violent-as-fuck, and with Uncharted-ish gameplay? Yes please. Naughty Dog has already made my two favorite game franchises (Jak and Uncharted), and this one looks to join them.
I did LOL though when it was announced that Ellen Page is the lead in Beyond, because so many people have been saying how the girl in The Last of Us looks like her for a while.