I'd like to see them play a set that used songs from their full discography. All 5 albums, Call Of The Mastodon, and even singles like Deathbound or Cut You Up With A Linoleum Knife. I think it'd be funny....
I'm not too good at making actual setlists, but these are the songs I haven't seen that I really want to
Shadows The Move
Battle at Sea
Hand Of Stone
This Mortal Soil
Also, Hearts Alive is the best closer ever, so that again would be hella good.
4/10 Neutral Milk Hotel
4/19-20 Thou/Cloud Rat