I couldn't have written a better setlist. This was my 16th time seeing Metallica but still heard 4 songs I had not heard before (Shortest Straw, My Apocalypse, Judas Kiss, Trapped Under Ice). Other highlights for me were Creeping Death, Fade To Black, and Dyers Eve.
My pictures from the show:
http://pictures.leglessmoof.net/v/concerts/2009_11_15/