PDA

View Full Version : The Official Metal Setlists Top Albums of 2007 Results


DethMaiden
01-15-2008, 05:22 PM
1. Symphony X- Paradise Lost
http://www.insideout.de/catalog/images/SymphonyXParadiseLost300.jpg

2. Porcupine Tree- Fear of a Blank Planet
http://mixtapemagazin.files.wordpress.com/2007/04/porcupine_tree_foabp.jpg

3. Between the Buried and Me- Colors
http://cdn.last.fm/coverart/300x300/3402965-2076242359.jpg

4. Redemption- The Origins of Ruin
http://cdn.last.fm/coverart/300x300/3268376.jpg

5. Clutch- From Beale Street to Oblivion
http://static.rateyourmusic.com/album_images/740082.jpg

6. Dream Theater- Systematic Chaos
http://img502.imageshack.us/img502/162/dtsceh5.jpg

7. Gamma Ray- Land of the Free II
http://www.metalkingdom.net/album/img/d23/5022.jpg

8. Tegan and Sara- The Con
http://2.music.bigpond-images.com/images/AlbumCoverArt/274/XXL/The-Con.jpg

9. Nightwish- Dark Passion Play
http://www.nightwish-italy.com/immagini/album/dark_passion_play_300.jpg

10. Pig Destroyer- Phantom Limb
http://panther1.last.fm/coverart/300x300/3292102.jpg


Honorable Mentions:
11. Nine Inch Nails- Year Zero
12. Threshold- Dead Reckoning
13. King Diamond- Give Me Your Soul...Please
14. Masterplan- MK II
15. Three- The End Is Begun
16. Bloodbound- Book of the Dead
17. Helloween- Gambling With the Devil
18. Rush- Snakes & Arrows
19. 3 Inches of Blood- Fire Up the Blades
20. Pink Cream 69- In10sity
21. Behemoth- The Apostasy
22. Therion- Gothic Kabbalah
23. Ensiferum- Victory Songs
24. Epica- The Divine Conspiracy
25. The Dillinger Escape Plan- Ire Works


**28 lists were submitted, resulting in 150 total albums receiving votes.

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 05:24 PM
8. Tegan and Sara- The Con
http://2.music.bigpond-images.com/images/AlbumCoverArt/274/XXL/The-Con.jpg
:party::party::party::party::party::party:

Forget football, this is the upset of the year :D

overkiller
01-15-2008, 05:25 PM
lol.

overkiller
01-15-2008, 05:25 PM
:party::party::party::party::party::party:

Forget football, this is the upset of the year :D

:lol: :rocker:

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 05:26 PM
That alone makes up for the fact that most of the list is crap, as usual.

overkiller
01-15-2008, 05:28 PM
That alone makes up for the fact that most of the list is crap, as usual.

Agreed. :D

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 05:29 PM
If it had placed better than Dream Theater, I would have died of joy :D

DethMaiden
01-15-2008, 05:32 PM
Well, in my professional opinion:

1. Lame. Seriously, not a good album, let alone top 10, let alone fucking album of the year.
2. Second straight year my #1 has been the board's #2.
3. I'm actually proud of the board for putting it this high :D
4. Really good album, even if it's "safe mediocrity" :tongue:
5. Who hates Clutch? I mean, really. Good call putting them in the top 10.
6. Awful album that is everything wrong with progressive metal.
7. Okay, it's Gamma Ray. Skip.
8. I honestly wanted to like this album more than I did based on the myspace songs I heard, but on principle alone, this is fucking awesome.
9. Lame. What I heard sounded like the soundtrack to a boring game of Dungeons & Dragons: Circle Jerk Edition.
10. Most brutal album to ever make our site list, I think. Awesome!

ravenheart
01-15-2008, 06:04 PM
Hmmm. In my own (actually) professional opinion:

1. Fair enough. It's a great album. It made my top ten. Not number one, but certainly the most widely appreciated album on these boards, so a deserving winner.
2. Good album. Continues a trend of decent PT albums, but there were better prog albums this year.
3. No comment.
4. Good, solid album. Not exactly ground breaking, but steers well clear of boring as well.
5. Great band. Their most boring and unimaginative album. Doesn't deserve it just because they can do 100 times better. And why doesn't it get a cover?
6. Way better than Octatedium but not a top ten album.
7. Terrible. If pushing the envelope is one extreme, this is folding up in the corner, probably not even being noticed and getting thrown in the trash by mistake.
8. Never understood it. Never will. Not commenting.
9. Only decent album they've ever made. Contains my personal track of the year (Poet And The Pendulum) but not a top ten album. Wish he'd stick to making Tarot albums, to be honest.
10. About as good as death metal gets (without being Opeth anyway), and comfortably their best effort, but too one-dimensional to be a top ten album.

DethMaiden
01-15-2008, 06:16 PM
Hmmm. In my own (actually) professional opinion:


Dick ;)

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 06:17 PM
Hey, I've been paid for musical reviews too, so that makes me a professional ;)

overkiller
01-15-2008, 06:19 PM
Hmmm. In my own (actually) professional opinion:


:tp:

10. About as good as death metal gets (without being Opeth anyway)

:tp::tp:

theclansman1114
01-15-2008, 06:21 PM
7. Terrible. If pushing the envelope is one extreme, this is folding up in the corner, probably not even being noticed and getting thrown in the trash by mistake.

:confused::tp:

SomewhereInTime72
01-15-2008, 06:44 PM
My thoughts on the list:
1. While not my favorite, it certainly came close, and clearly was liked by so many people here, so I think it's fair enough that this one.
2. Love the band, didn't love the album. Whatever.
3. Aw what the fuck.
4. A lot of people like this album but I just don't get the hype. This was boring .
5. Same thing.
6. This makes United Abominations look like Rust In Peace. Bullshit.
7. Give me old Gamma Ray please.
8. Hah, I heard a few songs, not my thing. But it's placement here is... interesting. :D
9. Just when you thought Nightwish couldn't get any worse...
10. Once again, not my thing. So... whatever.

I think I actually like 11-20 a lot better.

theclansman1114
01-15-2008, 06:53 PM
7. Give me old Gamma Ray please.

Hopefully you don't mean Ralf Scheepers old.

ChildrenofSodom
01-15-2008, 06:57 PM
Tegan and Sara? Seriously? Metalshitlists has failed.

DethMaiden
01-15-2008, 06:58 PM
Tegan and Sara? Seriously? Metalshitlists has failed.

Nay, it has succeeded. Fuck single-mindedness.

EDIT: The real failure is our apparent complacency in propelling Paradise Lost to #1.

theWolfisLOOSE
01-15-2008, 07:11 PM
Why in the world you put Dillinger Escape Plan in the honorable mentions? Just cut off the list... they have to be the most obnoxious band in history.

SomewhereInTime72
01-15-2008, 07:14 PM
On the bright side... at least its not the WTF that this list is: http://www.metal-rules.com/polls/index.php?id=15

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 07:25 PM
Tegan and Sara? Seriously? Metalshitlists has failed.
If it makes you feel any better, only three people put it on their lists ;)

overkiller
01-15-2008, 07:26 PM
Nay, it has succeeded. Fuck single-mindedness.

EDIT: The real failure is our apparent complacency in propelling Paradise Lost to #1.

Agreed on both counts.



Though, like Nick said, only 3 people voted for it. :cool:

ChildrenofSodom
01-15-2008, 07:30 PM
Nay, it has succeeded. Fuck single-mindedness.

EDIT: The real failure is our apparent complacency in propelling Paradise Lost to #1.

You can't support crappy music on 'principle.' I dont give a shit if it isnt metal, if it sucks, it sucks.

overkiller
01-15-2008, 07:30 PM
You can't support crappy music on 'principle.' I dont give a shit if it isnt metal, if it sucks, it sucks.

:lol: Did you even hear it?

ChildrenofSodom
01-15-2008, 07:30 PM
On the bright side... at least its not the WTF that this list is: http://www.metal-rules.com/polls/index.php?id=15

LULZicedearth

Spiral_Slave
01-15-2008, 07:31 PM
I had no clue what Tegan and Sara was until right now. Wow. :hecho:

ChildrenofSodom
01-15-2008, 07:31 PM
:lol: Did you even hear it?

:lol: Yes :lol:


:eyes:

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 07:31 PM
HAHAHAHAHA. Suck it haters :fingers:

ChildrenofSodom
01-15-2008, 07:36 PM
8. I honestly wanted to like this album more than I did based on the myspace songs I heard, but on principle alone, this is fucking awesome.


That doesnt make any sense. Sorry.

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 07:38 PM
I don't care what anyone says, democracy DOES work.

DethMaiden
01-15-2008, 07:45 PM
That doesnt make any sense. Sorry.

I like the fact that the album made the list because it shows that we aren't all numbskulled heavy-metal-or-no-metal-at-all assholes. For the same reason, I'm incredibly impressed that Porcupine Tree managed second place.

I don't care what anyone says, democracy DOES work.

:lol: :fist:

ChildrenofSodom
01-15-2008, 07:48 PM
I like the fact that the album made the list because it shows that we aren't all numbskulled heavy-metal-or-no-metal-at-all assholes. For the same reason, I'm incredibly impressed that Porcupine Tree managed second place.



:lol: :fist:

Yeah..Porcupine Tree fucking rules. In fact, it should have been one. But Tegan and Sara? ha.

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 07:53 PM
I feel like I should inform them of their triumphant victory over the forces of power metal via Myspace :D

Spiral_Slave
01-15-2008, 07:54 PM
We're celebrating a pop album in the top ten albums of the year? On a metal music forum? :confused:

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 07:56 PM
We're celebrating a pop album in the top ten albums of the year? On a metal music forum? :confused:
It's top 10 albums of the year, not top 10 metal albums of the year.

Spiral_Slave
01-15-2008, 08:02 PM
It's top 10 albums of the year, not top 10 metal albums of the year.

Yeah but I mean come on, this is a metal forum. METALsetlists?

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 08:04 PM
It may shock you, but not everyone here listens to metal 24 hours a day. I listened to quite a few metal albums this year, many of which were awesome, but at the end of the day The Con was more interesting, unique and creative than any of them. I fail to see the problem here.

ChildrenofSodom
01-15-2008, 08:15 PM
We're celebrating a pop album in the top ten albums of the year? On a metal music forum? :confused:

Hipsters like being ironic.

ChildrenofSodom
01-15-2008, 08:15 PM
It may shock you, but not everyone here listens to metal 24 hours a day. I listened to quite a few metal albums this year, many of which were awesome, but at the end of the day The Con was more interesting, unique and creative than any of them. I fail to see the problem here.

Interesting, maybe. Unique and creative, no. I have heard that style of music done by ALOT of bands. Nothing special about them.

overkiller
01-15-2008, 08:33 PM
Yeah but I mean come on, this is a metal forum. METALsetlists?

It's also a tightly-knit community of very few members who have grown and evolved together musically. We don't have enough members to only talk about metal here. We talk about music. It just happens that most of us listen to metal more so than other things.

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 08:36 PM
Unique and creative, no. I have heard that style of music done by ALOT of bands. Nothing special about them.I find that hard to believe, seeing as I listen to a lot more of this kind of stuff than you do, and there definitely are not many bands who sound like them, especially the more experimental songs.

ADD
01-15-2008, 10:31 PM
Can we see a comparison of top 10 lists from the past couple years? I'm thinking this is the worst so far.

powerslave_85
01-15-2008, 10:39 PM
Do those threads even still exist?

ravenheart
01-16-2008, 02:05 AM
Dick ;)

Had to be done ;)

ravenheart
01-16-2008, 02:10 AM
I'm all for diversity. There're plenty of non-metal records in my top albums of 2007. But like someone already said, shit is shit, and Tegan And Sara is generic, shit teen-pop (although I do appreciate most of you are but kids ;))

ravenheart
01-16-2008, 02:18 AM
On the bright side... at least its not the WTF that this list is: http://www.metal-rules.com/polls/index.php?id=15

Christ... Megadeth, Dream Theater, Iced Earth, Helloween and Gamma Ray in the top ten?

Didn't the Onslaught album come out in '06?

But the only thing they got close to right was getting Primordial and Symphorce in the top 20.

You can tell the top ten is voting for names, the next ten is voting for records.

DethMaiden
01-16-2008, 05:14 AM
Can we see a comparison of top 10 lists from the past couple years? I'm thinking this is the worst so far.

I'll look around.

Maiden33
01-16-2008, 06:44 AM
I know as soon as I weigh in here this is gonna go straight to hell, but I can't help myself:

I don't really see the point in doing a year-end voting album voting thread because there's too few people here and too diverse of tastes, so the results always come out pretty distorted and no one winds up happy. The cliques vote their 1 or 2 albums they love into the top 10, and most everyone bitches about the other stuff.
Contrary to what Brad argued with me on AIM last night, I don't believe the purpose of this list should be to showcase our "diversity" as a board.
As I understand it, a top 10 voting thread is to get a general feel for the best albums of the year through discussing and voting on them... not to become a pissing match for a bunch of hypocritical martyrs for diversity, which is all anything like this ever is on this board.

powerslave_85
01-16-2008, 09:21 AM
As I understand it, a top 10 voting thread is to get a general feel for the best albums of the year through discussing and voting on them...Isn't that what we did? A couple of anomalies aside, the final list ended up being pretty fucking predictable. Besides, if you ask me, the overall top 10 is almost meaningless, because IMO the purpose of this whole exercise is to get us all to think critically about the music we listened to over the course of the year, and maybe in the process enjoy it more and find things about those albums we didn't notice the first time. And, along the way, discuss and debate the albums we had in common and help people find new things to listen to (there's definitely a few albums on my list that I wouldn't have bothered with if people here hadn't recommended them).

But yeah, I guess none of that matters because a pop album made it in the top 10 :tp:

JRA
01-16-2008, 10:04 AM
:lol: Did you even hear it?

I have. Honestly I don't know what it is about the "girl with the acoustic guitar" schtick that I think is cheesy and played out, especially since the only other woman I can think of that's done it is Joan Baez. Now with that being said, I listen to the vocals, and I understand what feel and what sound she's attempting to achieve, but she's missing it just barely. As a result it creates a very grating affect for my ears.

EvilCheeseWedge
01-16-2008, 10:27 AM
The fact that Megadeth isn't even in the top 25 is a sign of hope imo. Unfortunately, King Diamond being #13 (lololololololololol) kind of shatters that.

overkiller
01-16-2008, 11:36 AM
I'm all for diversity. There're plenty of non-metal records in my top albums of 2007. But like someone already said, shit is shit, and Tegan And Sara is generic, shit teen-pop (although I do appreciate most of you are but kids ;))

The three people who voted for it are in their 20s or 30s.

JRA
01-16-2008, 11:38 AM
The three people who voted for it are in their 20s or 30s.

Out of curiosity, how often did you actually listen to it?

overkiller
01-16-2008, 11:39 AM
Out of curiosity, how often did you actually listen to it?

I listened to it more when I first heard about it. I can't really say.

Div
01-16-2008, 01:49 PM
╔╗╔═╦╗
║╚╣║║╚╗
╚═╩═╩═╝

@

this thread

overkiller
01-16-2008, 01:51 PM
a pop album made it in the top 10

http://www.nightwish-italy.com/immagini/album/dark_passion_play_300.jpg

powerslave_85
01-16-2008, 02:08 PM
:lol: :lol:

DethMaiden
01-16-2008, 07:18 PM
2006:

1. Iron Maiden- A Matter of Life and Death
2. Mastodon- Blood Mountain
3. Amon Amarth- With Oden On Our Side
4. Queensrÿche- Operation: Mindcrime II
5. Blind Guardian- A Twist in the Myth
6. Edguy- Rocket Ride
7. I- Between Two Worlds
8. Tool- 10,000 Days
9. Circle II Circle- Burden of Truth
10. Slayer- Christ Illusion

2005:

1. Opeth- Ghost Reveries
2. Judas Priest- Angel of Retribution
3. Bruce Dickinson- Tyranny of Souls
4. Nevermore- This Godless Endeavor
5. Clutch- Robot Hive/Exodus
6. Children of Bodom- Are You Dead Yet?
7. Kamelot- The Black Halo
8. Iommi- Fused
9. Moonsorrow- Verisakeet
10. Candlemass- Candlemass

There ya go, Addi. :fist:

overkiller
01-16-2008, 07:27 PM
2006:

1. Iron Maiden- A Matter of Life and Death
2. Mastodon- Blood Mountain
3. Amon Amarth- With Oden On Our Side
4. Queensrÿche- Operation: Mindcrime II
5. Blind Guardian- A Twist in the Myth
6. Edguy- Rocket Ride
7. I- Between Two Worlds
8. Tool- 10,000 Days
9. Circle II Circle- Burden of Truth
10. Slayer- Christ Illusion

2005:

1. Opeth- Ghost Reveries
2. Judas Priest- Angel of Retribution
3. Bruce Dickinson- Tyranny of Souls
4. Nevermore- This Godless Endeavor
5. Clutch- Robot Hive/Exodus
6. Children of Bodom- Are You Dead Yet?
7. Kamelot- The Black Halo
8. Iommi- Fused
9. Moonsorrow- Verisakeet
10. Candlemass- Candlemass

There ya go, Addi. :fist:



Wow, yeah. I mean, neither of those lists are great, but fuck, this years is absolutely awful in comparison. I remember complaining to no end about 2006's... but it's actually got some good stuff, 3 that were in my top 10. :eyes:

ChildrenofSodom
01-16-2008, 07:34 PM
Wow, yeah. I mean, neither of those lists are great, but fuck, this years is absolutely awful in comparison. I remember complaining to no end about 2006's... but it's actually got some good stuff, 3 that were in my top 10. :eyes:


both of those lists fucking slay.

TonyD
02-09-2008, 10:53 PM
I have to say that 05-06 were both better than this year.
And HOW THE FUCK does Tegan and Sara get in the top 10, but High on Fire fails to make top 20?

zgodt
02-10-2008, 08:47 AM
I have to say that 05-06 were both better than this year.
And HOW THE FUCK does Tegan and Sara get in the top 10, but High on Fire fails to make top 20?

Tegan and Sara have better riffs?

Div
02-10-2008, 09:25 AM
I have to say that 05-06 were both better than this year.
And HOW THE FUCK does Tegan and Sara get in the top 10, but High on Fire fails to make top 20?



our community is very small, and the way the voting system is set up, you only need a few people to put it in their top 3 for it to get a top spot in the end results

TonyD
02-10-2008, 01:50 PM
Thats what I figured, 24 points right there.

Tegan and Sara have better riffs?
Or maybe thats why.