Manowar vs Edguy vs Hammerfall

[jaysadler2]

who's the best and why?

I cant decide!

:mad:

[theclansman1114]

Easy, Edguy.

Just listen to them. Manowar and Hammerfall are extremely cheesey. And I am a huge Manowar fan. Over the past few years Hammerfall have really fallen in my eyes. They're just... I dunno, kind of lame really. I do enjoy Manowar much more than Hammerfall. Yea they have been doing the same stuff forever, but thats it right there I guess, their anthems are great and they've stayed true to their cause of true metal haha. Which brings me to Edguy, my second favorite Power Metal band. They easily beat out Hammerfall and Manowar based on music alone. And their joke songs are hilarious.

Edguy>Manowar>Hammerfall

[zgodt]

I'd rather listen to Justin Timberlake than any of them.

[theclansman1114]

I'd rather listen to Justin Timberlake than any of them.

:rolleyes: :rolleyes: Then go and do it.

[EvilCheeseWedge]

I'd rather listen to Justin Timberlake than any of them.
:lol:

+1

[powerslave_85]

Where's the "none of the above" option?

[overkiller]

Oh come on.

[ADD]

Edguy because they don't suck.

[zgodt]

:rolleyes: :rolleyes: Then go and do it.
Well, naturally, there are also about 10,000 things I'd rather listen to instead of Justin Timberlake. :)

The new Dinosaur Jr. album for example. :rocker:

[Div]

Those other bands arent even in the same league as Manowar.

Hail and Kill! :mad:

[SomewhereInTime72]

Easy, Edguy.

Just listen to them. Manowar and Hammerfall are extremely cheesey. And I am a huge Manowar fan. Over the past few years Hammerfall have really fallen in my eyes. They're just... I dunno, kind of lame really. I do enjoy Manowar much more than Hammerfall. Yea they have been doing the same stuff forever, but thats it right there I guess, their anthems are great and they've stayed true to their cause of true metal haha. Which brings me to Edguy, my second favorite Power Metal band. They easily beat out Hammerfall and Manowar based on music alone. And their joke songs are hilarious.

Edguy>Manowar>Hammerfall

Thats it but I'm not really a huge fan of any of these bands.... But you basically nailed it for me too. :cool:

[powerslave_85]

I will say that at least Edguy doesn't take themselves too seriously, and at least they know they're cheesy.

[DreamEvil001]

Edguy because they don't suck.

how can you beat that argument? edguy by far

[MetalDrummer888]

edguy hands down :hecho:

[MetalDrummer888]

Edguy because they are the shit.

improved :tongue:

[Maiden33]

Edguy is so much better than the other two it's not even funny. I shouldn't even have to explain why.

[ADD]

improved :tongue:
:metal:

[es156]

Edguy because they don't suck.

:agree:

[Div]

http://www.minigunmen.net/manowar.jpg


HEAVY METAL OR NO METAL AT ALL!!!!!
:mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

[Div]

OTHER BANDS PLAY...


http://www.hudebni-scena.cz/downloads/wallpapers/detail/manowar-music-wallpaper.jpg


...MANOWAR KILLS!!!

:finger2: :finger2: :finger2: :finger2: :finger2: :finger2: :finger2: :finger2:

[DreamEvil001]

http://www.minigunmen.net/manowar.jpg


HEAVY METAL OR NO METAL AT ALL!!!!!
:mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

that guy on the far right looks so pathetic trying to be badass

[Div]

Karl Logan kicks ass! :cool:

http://www.manowar.art.pl/images/stories/logan.jpg

[JRA]

Karl Logan kicks ass! :cool:

http://www.manowar.art.pl/images/stories/logan.jpg

Too bad he downtunes.:mad:

[ozz3]

I like them all but I'm not a fan of any of them...

I choose HammerFall. :party:

[DethMaiden]

Edguy are the only one of those I can listen to without lol'ing. Except when they're trying to be funny, which they're also quite good at.

[JRA]

Is it just me or would Edguy and Hammerfall not exist without Manowar?

[DethMaiden]

Is it just me or would Edguy and Hammerfall not exist without Manowar?

It's just you. Rainbow had opened the power metal floodgates long before.

[Happy Bunny]

I like ManOwaR but, Karl, my man....bangs are not metal.

[Div]

Manowar has nothing to do with power metal :mad:

[JRA]

I'd just like to say that Keeper Of The Seven Keys Pt. II owns all these bands.:)

[overkiller]

Is it just me or would Edguy and Hammerfall not exist without Manowar?

You are correct, at least on the Hammerfall count.

[ChildrenofSodom]

They arent even similar enough to say which is better. I like Edguy the most, overall. Hammerfall are pretty cool, and Manowar are Manowar.....of course. But Edguy have a wider variety of sound/genres and their lyrics are full of the least cheese.

[ADD]

I'd just like to say that Keeper Of The Seven Keys Pt. II owns all these bands.:)
Seconded.

[Fe Maiden]

I'd just like to say that Keeper Of The Seven Keys Pt. II owns all these bands.:)True indeed!