PDA

View Full Version : Ultimate Metal Band Round 2


sneakbobcat
12-18-2006, 01:12 PM
Ok, this is Round 2. Again all will be picked at Random. So let's see who gets knocked off this round. We have seen away with bands like Guns N Roses, Mastodon and Lamb Of God. Who will leave this time?

Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

ACDC vs Children Of Bodom

There is one option with three. May i remind everyone to vote for either Heaven & Hell or System Of A Down/Amorphis

THREAD WILL CLOSE WEDNESDAY.

sneakbobcat
12-18-2006, 01:13 PM
Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

ACDC vs Children Of Bodom

DethMaiden
12-18-2006, 01:15 PM
Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

ADD
12-18-2006, 01:27 PM
I refuse to vote for a band called "Heaven & Hell" since they have not released any studio albums to my knowledge. If someone could point me to check out an album by the artist "Heaven & Hell" I'd be much obliged.

ADD
12-18-2006, 01:30 PM
Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

Wrathchild_84
12-18-2006, 01:31 PM
Iron Maiden

Venom

Heaven And Hell

King Diamond

Overkill

Motorhead

Death

Anthrax

Blaze

Voivod

Megadeth (Opeth suck)

Testament

Slayer

Helloween

Black Sabbath

Children Of Bodom

JRA
12-18-2006, 01:36 PM
Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest



Are you trying to get rid of Judas Priest?

sneakbobcat
12-18-2006, 01:40 PM
Are you trying to get rid of Judas Priest?

It was done at Random.

DreamEvil001
12-18-2006, 02:15 PM
I refuse to vote for a band called "Heaven & Hell" since they have not released any studio albums to my knowledge. If someone could point me to check out an album by the artist "Heaven & Hell" I'd be much obliged.

Mob Rules, Live Evil, and Dehumanizer off the top of my head:tp:

DreamEvil001
12-18-2006, 02:17 PM
Ok, this is Round 2. Again all will be picked at Random. So let's see who gets knocked off this round. We have seen away with bands like Guns N Roses, Mastodon and Lamb Of God. Who will leave this time?

Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

There is one option with three. May i remind everyone to vote for either Heaven & Hell or System Of A Down/Amorphis

THREAD WILL CLOSE WEDNESDAY.

Who won between Children of Bodom-Killswitch and AC/DC-Masterplan?

ADD
12-18-2006, 02:26 PM
Mob Rules, Live Evil, and Dehumanizer off the top of my head:tp:
I believe that band was called "Black Sabbath", but I could be wrong. Hmm, lemme go check the CD covers............funny, says "Black Sabbath." Hmm, how about my vinyl copies...........hey hey hey whadya know, "Black Sabbath." They've even got it inside the booklets, and on the CD itself, and on the back cover, and on the inner sleeve, and on the LP, yeah, strange.

:rolleyes:

es156
12-18-2006, 02:32 PM
I believe that band was called "Black Sabbath", but I could be wrong. Hmm, lemme go check the CD covers............funny, says "Black Sabbath." Hmm, how about my vinyl copies...........hey hey hey whadya know, "Black Sabbath." They've even got it inside the booklets, and on the CD itself, and on the back cover, and on the inner sleeve, and on the LP, yeah, strange.

:rolleyes:

:lol:

JRA
12-18-2006, 03:29 PM
Iron Maiden

Dio

Heaven & Hell

King Diamond

Overkill

Motorhead

Death

Anthrax

Pantera

Led Zeppelin

Megadeth

Edguy

Slayer

Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath

AC/DC

SomewhereInTime72
12-18-2006, 03:55 PM
I believe that band was called "Black Sabbath", but I could be wrong. Hmm, lemme go check the CD covers............funny, says "Black Sabbath." Hmm, how about my vinyl copies...........hey hey hey whadya know, "Black Sabbath." They've even got it inside the booklets, and on the CD itself, and on the back cover, and on the inner sleeve, and on the LP, yeah, strange.

:rolleyes:

Amorphis is better anyway.


Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

ChildrenofSodom
12-18-2006, 06:04 PM
Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera



Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

Div
12-18-2006, 08:40 PM
Iron Maiden

Dio

Heaven & Hell

King Diamond

Overkill

Motorhead

Pink Floyd

Anthrax

Pantera

Led Zeppelin

Megadeth

Edguy

Queensryche

Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath


I'm doing this just to help make sure SOAD gets kicked the fuck out of this contest asap.

es156
12-19-2006, 04:54 AM
Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

Angelripper
12-19-2006, 06:22 AM
Ok, this is Round 2. Again all will be picked at Random. So let's see who gets knocked off this round. We have seen away with bands like Guns N Roses, Mastodon and Lamb Of God. Who will leave this time?

Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

There is one option with three. May i remind everyone to vote for either Heaven & Hell or System Of A Down/Amorphis

THREAD WILL CLOSE WEDNESDAY.
.

zgodt
12-19-2006, 06:29 AM
Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater (neither)

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray (neither)

Black Sabbath v Rush

tmactaggart
12-19-2006, 07:51 AM
Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater
Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead
Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

sneakbobcat
12-19-2006, 09:29 AM
Sorry about that error, when i was transferring the bands i missed out one of the ties. ACDC vs Bodom.

DreamEvil001
12-19-2006, 10:00 AM
Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

AC/DC vs Children Of Bodom

DreamEvil001
12-19-2006, 10:16 AM
I believe that band was called "Black Sabbath", but I could be wrong. Hmm, lemme go check the CD covers............funny, says "Black Sabbath." Hmm, how about my vinyl copies...........hey hey hey whadya know, "Black Sabbath." They've even got it inside the booklets, and on the CD itself, and on the back cover, and on the inner sleeve, and on the LP, yeah, strange.

:rolleyes:

what the fuck's in the name? who cares about legal hassels? its the same people playing the same songs

MetalDrummer888
12-19-2006, 10:28 AM
Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

ACDC vs Children Of Bodom

ChildrenofSodom
12-19-2006, 01:10 PM
what the fuck's in the name? who cares about legal hassels? its the same people playing the same songs

you have to admit Dio-Sabbath has a different sound/feel than Ozzy-Sabbath.

ADD
12-19-2006, 03:48 PM
what the fuck's in the name? who cares about legal hassels? its the same people playing the same songs

Huh :confused:

JRA
12-19-2006, 04:11 PM
you have to admit Dio-Sabbath has a different sound/feel than Ozzy-Sabbath.

Dehumanizer doesn't.

ChildrenofSodom
12-19-2006, 04:49 PM
Dehumanizer doesn't.

i think it does

Maiden33
12-19-2006, 05:52 PM
Iron Maiden vs Judas Priest

Venom vs Dio

Heaven & Hell vs System Of A Down/Amorphis

King Diamond vs Dream Theater

Overkill vs Stratovarius

Rage Against The Machine vs Motorhead

Death vs Pink Floyd

Tool vs Anthrax

Blaze vs Pantera

Led Zeppelin vs Voivod

Opeth vs Megadeth

Edguy vs Testament

Slayer vs Queensryche

Helloween vs Gamma Ray

Black Sabbath v Rush

ACDC vs Children Of Bodom


You put Helloween against Gamma Ray. That was uncalled for. You will pay for this... I'm just not sure when or how though. Though no one will vote for them, Gamma Ray is about 5 times the band Helloween could've ever been. Kai Hansen was the genius behind Helloween and he took his talent elsewhere, to a band that has given us some of the finest true power metal albums ever made. Listen to the Land of the Free. I still respect Helloween for getting their first, band the band has released 1 good album in the past decade or more.
Also, people on this board are LAME for voting Masterplan out in favor of ACDC.
And yes, I left one or two blank, cause I really can't cast a meaningful vote either way.

Div
12-19-2006, 06:41 PM
Also, people on this board are LAME



It's not that hard to figure that out, soon as you see SOAD on a list for "Ultimate Metal Bands" :lol: :hecho:

ChildrenofSodom
12-19-2006, 06:47 PM
It's not that hard to figure that out, soon as you see SOAD on a list for "Ultimate Metal Bands" :lol: :hecho:

amen to that....:allan:

Maiden33
12-19-2006, 07:06 PM
It's not that hard to figure that out, soon as you see SOAD on a list for "Ultimate Metal Bands" :lol: :hecho:

This is true.

But it's just absurd. ACDC were a generic rock band that made less than 10 original songs in their entire career, and just duplicated and duplicated them, even though they weren't all that great and innovative in the first place. The vocals are attrocious, and the band is basically a completely overblown cliche. Oooh let's sing about hell, women, and rock and roll!!!!!
Masterplan on the other hand is one hell of a melodic/power metal band that has released 2 BRILLIANT albums, and has what I expect to be their best yet on the way... Out of this world vocals, great songwriting, and killer musicianship... not to mention, they're actually a serious band.

zanthir
12-19-2006, 07:35 PM
Iron Maiden

Dio

System Of A Down/Amorphis

Dream Theater

Stratovarius
Motorhead

Pink Floyd

Tool

Blaze

Led Zeppelin

Megadeth

Testament

Queensryche

Helloween

Black Sabbath

Children of Bodom

Div
12-19-2006, 08:03 PM
This is true.

But it's just absurd. ACDC were a generic rock band that made less than 10 original songs in their entire career, and just duplicated and duplicated them, even though they weren't all that great and innovative in the first place. The vocals are attrocious, and the band is basically a completely overblown cliche. Oooh let's sing about hell, women, and rock and roll!!!!!
Masterplan on the other hand is one hell of a melodic/power metal band that has released 2 BRILLIANT albums, and has what I expect to be their best yet on the way... Out of this world vocals, great songwriting, and killer musicianship... not to mention, they're actually a serious band.


Yea I never saw what the big deal was with ACDC in the first place. I think even Ted Nugent is a better singer than Angus :lol:

Angelripper
12-19-2006, 09:02 PM
Yea I never saw what the big deal was with ACDC in the first place. I think even Ted Nugent is a better singer than Angus :lol:
Uh huh. I think the lack of attention you've been paying to AC/DC is obvious.

This is true.

But it's just absurd. ACDC were a generic rock band that made less than 10 original songs in their entire career, and just duplicated and duplicated them, even though they weren't all that great and innovative in the first place. The vocals are attrocious, and the band is basically a completely overblown cliche. Oooh let's sing about hell, women, and rock and roll!!!!!
Masterplan on the other hand is one hell of a melodic/power metal band that has released 2 BRILLIANT albums, and has what I expect to be their best yet on the way... Out of this world vocals, great songwriting, and killer musicianship... not to mention, they're actually a serious band.
Well, I've got both Masterplan albums and haven't even got all the AC/DC albums. And guess what? AC/DC have released more great albums than Masterplan. Powerage, Highway to Hell, Dirty Deeds, The Razor's Edge.

Oh, and Back in Black. Only one of the most successful Rock albums ever released.

ADD
12-19-2006, 09:16 PM
There's no way to really prove one band is better than another. I happen to just prefer AC/DC to Masterplan. I like their sound more, and I can identify better with them than some geeky fantasy power metal dudes. Not much else to say.

Div
12-19-2006, 10:23 PM
lol @ me

JRA
12-20-2006, 05:23 AM
There's no way to really prove one band is better than another. I happen to just prefer AC/DC to Masterplan. I like their sound more, and I can identify better with them than some geeky fantasy power metal dudes. Not much else to say.


...yea.

MetalDrummer888
12-20-2006, 08:59 AM
maiden had better win this :bouville:

sneakbobcat
12-20-2006, 09:08 AM
Would you rather this idea just stopped? There seems to be so much complaining about it, that maybe that's the best option? Anyone?

es156
12-20-2006, 09:18 AM
Would you rather this idea just stopped? There seems to be so much complaining about it, that maybe that's the best option? Anyone?

If you stopped a project every time someone complained nothing would ever get done. Besides, a thread like this is bound to spark some debate.

sneakbobcat
12-20-2006, 10:02 AM
If you stopped a project every time someone complained nothing would ever get done. Besides, a thread like this is bound to spark some debate.

ok.. Well i've counted up the votes and received some surprising results. - No Iron Maiden have not been knocked out. I'll commence Round 3 then if you wish. Thread Lock?

es156
12-20-2006, 04:48 PM
Thread Lock?

Done.